MLB's Salary Cap Fight Could Change Free Agency Forever
The 2026 MLB awards are in, and four major awards were unanimous. But while the MVP and Cy Young races produced little controversy, the National League Rookie of the Year voting certainly did.
In Episode 730 M & G discuss Pete Crow-Armstrong, Yordan Alvarez, Cam Schlittler, and Jacob Misiorowski. They debate Sal Stewart's controversial Rookie of the Year victory over Mets outfielder Carson Benge and whether voters placed too much emphasis on home runs and RBIs.
Then the conversation turns to the biggest story of the offseason: MLB's looming labor confrontation.
With a potential lockout approaching, could a proposed $258 million salary cap and $180 million salary floor reshape baseball? Would a cap really improve competitive balance? And what would happen to teams like the Mets and Dodgers, whose payroll commitments could exceed the proposed limits?
In this episode:
The unanimous MVP and Cy Young winners and the Rookie of the Year controversy.
Pat Murphy, Will Venable, and the Manager of the Year awards.
Why a salary floor might accomplish more than a salary cap.
Whether Shohei Ohtani's deferred compensation would work under a new system.
Why owners and players may both have reasons to avoid a prolonged work stoppage.
How labor uncertainty could encourage more one-year free-agent contracts.
What it might take for the Mets or Dodgers to sign Tarik Skubal.
Whether long-term contracts make sense when baseball's financial rules could change.
Will baseball's owners and players find common ground, or is another work stoppage inevitable?
Almost Cooperstown is a weekly baseball podcast featuring thoughtful conversations about the Baseball Hall of Fame, baseball history, current MLB topics, player comparisons, statistics and the stories that connect today's game with its rich history.
Thanks again to Mercury Maid for the Intro & Outro music.
Visit AlmostCooperstown.com for original baseball articles, subscribe wherever you listen to po
The 2026 MLB awards are in, and four major awards were unanimous. But while the MVP and Cy Young races produced little controversy, the National League Rookie of the Year voting certainly did.
In Episode 730 Mark and Gordon discuss the winners, including Pete Crow-Armstrong, Yordan Alvarez, Cam Schlittler, and Jacob Misiorowski. They debate Sal Stewart's controversial Rookie of the Year victory over Mets outfielder Carson Benge and whether voters placed too much emphasis on home runs and RBIs.
Then the conversation turns to the biggest story of the offseason: MLB's looming labor confrontation.
With a potential lockout approaching, could a proposed $258 million salary cap and $180 million salary floor reshape baseball? Would a cap really improve competitive balance? And what would happen to teams like the Mets and Dodgers, whose payroll commitments could exceed the proposed limits?
In this episode:
- The unanimous MVP and Cy Young winners and the Rookie of the Year controversy.
- Pat Murphy, Will Venable, and the Manager of the Year awards.
- Why a salary floor might accomplish more than a salary cap.
- Whether Shohei Ohtani's deferred compensation would work under a new system.
- Why owners and players may both have reasons to avoid a prolonged work stoppage.
- How labor uncertainty could encourage more one-year free-agent contracts.
- What it might take for the Mets or Dodgers to sign Tarik Skubal.
- Whether long-term contracts make sense when baseball's financial rules could change.
Will baseball's owners and players find common ground, or is another work stoppage inevitable?
Almost Cooperstown is a weekly baseball podcast featuring thoughtful conversations about the Baseball Hall of Fame, baseball history, current MLB topics, player comparisons, statistics and the stories that connect today's game with its rich history.
Thanks again to Mercury Maid for the Intro & Outro music.
Visit AlmostCooperstown.com for original baseball articles, subscribe wherever you listen to podcasts, and follow Almost Cooperstown on YouTube.
The awards are in and among our Cy Youngs and NVPs they are unanimous. And now we move into the offseason. Free agent sightings are begun. And hopefully it's not going to be a long one. It's this offseason in baseball.
We did pretty well on our picks, I thought, when it came to w I I think I guess wasn't too hard. Considering that four of them were unanimous. Right, and and we sort of kind of knew that and the discussion more was was there any reason for them not to be unanimous? And really across the board
Really think there was only one award that was contentious, and boy was it contentious. So wow are people mad about it. At least online. I haven't seen a response to the to a an award like what happened with the NL rookie of the year since I think that Rick Porcello, Justin Verland, or Cy Young race from like twenty fifteen or twenty sixteen. That was the last time I remember people being like, What? You're giving it to him? So I you know, we talked about it be you know in our last episode.
In terms of you know Sal Stewart being the favorite, even you know, before we said, and and yet we said that the award goes to the guy who had the best rookie season, not the guy who has probably gonna have the best career. And I when I looked at Carson Benge of the Mets, and he finished second, McLean, I think finished fourth, and JJ Weatherhold, I think finished third. Right, correct. I I think you know, I don't think there's much argument that most people might say that Carson Bench will have the better career than Sal Stewart.
The reason that he got consideration for rookie of the year w and even though he had a lower F war, he had a lot of lower overall stuff it was the thirty two homers, which was ninth in baseball or something like that. And a hundred and thirteen RBIs. And the Reds made the playoffs. That's a big part of it. And a big you have to also look at this way. Look, hundred and seventeen RBIs when you bat behind Del A Data Cruz, probably gonna get them. Flip side, you're not just gonna get thirty two home runs from batting in the major leagues. You actually gotta hit the ball. But I also
Almost Cooperstown (02:03.566)
Understand that people are like, okay, wait, he had 32 home runs at 117 RBIs and he had a 760 OPS. Eee. Okay. So I I think it's the sort of thing where look, look, long term, short term, I think both teams are probably happy that they have their guy on their team. I am sure red fans are extremely happy and proud, and they should be, of his win. I think Met fans, you have to look at it and say, look, there were only like five or six players that qualified as five tool players in the major leagues last year. And Carson Bench was.
one of them. And and I don't know what you make of this. You know, you had two Mets that were in the final f fo four, I believe. and and and do the two of them being in the they cancel each other out in any way did did one steal votes from the other? I I don't believe that stuff works that way. I don't think so either. Because doesn't really make sense when you you think about it because like why would they steal votes from each other? Because that wouldn't imply that you thought they were both the only way that works is because that's the thing is you would imply that you think they're both equally good. So like you would then vote for one for first in
One for second. There's not some like kind of weird situation where you think that they're equally good, but then there's some other guy that is still better than them. Like I just don't understand how the stealing votes would work in that situation. But aside from that, you know, so you had, you know, the awards the AL Cy Young, rightly so went to Camp Schlitler. Dylan Sees was a viable candidate that kind of you know wasn't being talked about as much as he should have because he really had a good season. Right, but it went to Schlitler unanimously. I I really don't know how much of
of a candidate C's can say he was. If you if the if the board gets candidate, you can make arguments that as I'm saying that C's deserved consideration. The AL Cy Young went to Cam Schlitzer and the NL Cy Young went to
Jake Jacob Jacob Mizarowski unanimously and we could both sit here and say, you know, let's think about the pitchers in the National League who had terrific years. Luzardo of the Phillies and Christopher Sanchez for that matter. had really, really good years. it was a year where Skeens didn't compete with Mizerowski for the Cy Young. So that's no good on Mizarowski. But let's be let's be real here. Mizorowski was even more sh so that I said think than Schlitler. He was so far and away Historically good. Especially
Almost Cooperstown (04:21.872)
Once Otani stopped starting. Because Otani was having an incredible year pitching. We kind of forget that because he he stopped pitching so early into the season. I will say this now. Shohe Otani will never pitch enough innings to win a Cy Young award in once in a season. I mean if Shohei Ottawa He was never gonna get there. If Shohei Otani wants to pitch, he needs to be a reliever.
Yeah, that's not gonna happen because he doesn't wanna do that and they're gonna let him do what he wants. But but if you I think if he wants to be an effective major league pitcher, that's what he would need to do. I don't think he can handle 'cause we saw we saw how it affected his batting this year for the most part. I I think it's just the sort of thing where if he's gonna be an the type of hitter the Dodgers need him to be, especially with Freddie and Mookie kind of starting to age out of their effectiveness
I don't think he can be a starting everyday starting pitcher too. But I think he could be a reliever because if he only has to come in and pitch one inning every couple of days, that's a lot easier to spot in on his body. Big problem with that. He doesn't want to do it. Right. Right. So so that's that's not gonna happen. I'm just saying in terms of in terms of ideal world, like like like that's the thing. If the players were, you know, puppets that we could aut you know, they were automatons we could tell what to do, I'm guessing that's what the Progers would probably go to. You just you can't
Do 'cause the show he doesn't want to do And you know, and think about it in the American League, where Schlitter wins unanimously, you know, Scuble is injured, he's out for two months, then he gets traded to the Dodgers. Overall, his body of work for the season between the two leagues is pretty darn good. Cy Young worthy if you were able to s isolate that, but it makes it easy when he doesn't pitch the whole season in the league. It makes it really easy, and certainly it's the sort of thing where whatever team that signs him next year, even though you know, as we're gonna talk about it
In no a little bit later here. It's a big risk going into what we is in an uncertain salary cap era, signing a guy like Tarek Scuble to what you're going to assume is a big long term contract. Right.
Almost Cooperstown (06:24.64)
You're probably getting a Cy Young year out of him next year. and and the AL rookie of the year ended up going to Kevin McGonagall. It wasn't unanimous. I think Parker Mesick got some votes. He was very good. He was very good. you know, but you know, he was that was another award that felt like it was you it was one of the awards that even though it was you wasn't unanimous, we all knew Kevin McGonagall was gonna win. And and and and deservedly so so the MVPs and we had MVPs. They were unanimous. They should have been unanimous. we talked about this two or three months.
Months ago, that we felt that it was there there was a done deal. Pete Crow Armstrong and Jordan Alvarez. Jordan was always more the done deal, I felt like there was always the outside chance that Shoei could have come back and hit enough to make the NL. Nordan, he plays in the other league. No, no, no, no. Shoei could have come back in the NL to make it interesting. Jordan was a done deal because there I didn't feel like there was anybody that was. Except that as DH, I kept thinking, you know, but there wasn't there wasn't a judge. Nobody could come out of there as and challenge a DH for it. Ramirez had such a lackluster record.
regular season. Vladdy forgot how to play baseball this year. Julio forgot how to play baseball for about like the first fifty or sixty games of the season. And so like outside of that, there's not a lot of crazy Junior Camonero, you know maybe maybe and you know I think going forward now, Camonero will get that kind of not. I think if he had that kind of I but I think also at the same time if you look at the seasons, Jordan's season was just just better than Camonero's season. And he did that on the on the back of basic which is
is an amazing first half, right? 'Cause he got off to such a a a great start and he kinda I don't want to say he coasted in, but he wasn't as dominant in the second half of the season as he was in the first half of But he was pretty good after that. So I I and to me having four unanimous not that it was wrong or anything like that, but it kinda made it boring because you can't argue about stuff when everybody's unanimous. Well right.
boring award season and maybe that's why the the at least online from what I saw on Twitter on discussion play on discussion boards and stuff like that the response to the NL rookie of the year was so vitriolic was I think in part because there was nothing to talk about in the other right you know you had you know manager of the year and Pat Murphy of the Brewers won his third straight this is the annual award now that goes to Pat Murphy. It it it felt like because he won the World Series even though we don't take the playoffs into consideration like it would have been weird to give it to
Almost Cooperstown (08:54.17)
him for two years and then not give it to him the year they win the World Series and his team is the best record in the national league. Yeah, and and they were a better regular season team this year than they've been in any of the other years, which considering he won the manager of the year the past two years, I guess makes sense. Right, right, right. And they were they were the best team almost wire to wire.
And who are you gonna give it to in the National League if you didn't give it to Pat Murphy? That's the other thing. Because it wasn't like the Dodgers sort of limped in. The Cubs were You're gonna give it to Don Mattingley who took over the Phillies job and got him into the playoffs. How about Walt Weiss of the Atlanta Braves first year manager? I I I think that would have been a you know right, right that but there wasn't really anybody in the national league that stood out like you know, you none of the young team you know you didn't have the pirates step up or or the the Reds step up. You didn't have any of the teams in the like the ne like the Padres, yeah, they played
Great in the second half, but they had to play great in the second half to rescue themselves after their terrible first half. So like there wasn't really another person to give it to. You know, the Giants fell apart, the Mets fell apart, any of the teams that would have been bounce back teams. So what what does Pat Murphy have to do to win his fourth straight manager of the year? Do they win every game? win a hundred and five plus games. If he wins a hundred and five games next year, he could get manager of the year. And in the American League, it ended up being and and I I I when we
Talked it's like who's it gonna be? Should it be Kevin Cash? You forget about you almost forget about him because you you for you you just forget it's like yeah, no, it had to be Will Venable. Well, and and Kevin Cash deserved consideration because I I and and we're culprits right at the top of the list going, you know, Tampa, not not only doubted him the whole I doubted him the whole I think I had him in like like near the bottom of the league of the of their division. We did not believe in them at all. So so good on them because they they obviously you know played great, went all the way to the World Series. and
And Will Venable's White Sox were probably and that's what the award is about, right? It's rewarding the surprising team. And so I guess the manager must have had something to do with that. But you would look at this White Sox team, and team they were a team that nobody was predicting to make the playoffs. Nobody was thinking they were going to do anything. And they turned it around, and most of the year. And the thing is, he was able to hold them together and get them able to get in over the finish line. When I think, and I think a where a lesser manager, especially a rookie manager that would have failed, or not necessarily a rookie manager, but another manager.
Almost Cooperstown (11:12.556)
Would have failed, that's where you would have stumbled, is you just wouldn't have been able to get it over the finish line. And there are some guys, you know, you could have given it to Chad Tracy of the Red Sox, right? You fire Alex Cora, and that's a bold move, by the way. It's it's more to me, it went more that the executive, like Craig Bresnaw, looked like he was out of his mind when he fired Alex Cora. And I guess he was right. And it turns out that not only was it right, the Red Sox rallied, made the playoffs, and Chad Tracy has got the job going forward.
I I understand, but you know, he he could have been a guy that was given consideration for that as well. But it was one by Will Van. I I I it wouldn't shock me if the White Sox
were ten games under five hundred next year actually. Right. If they play. If if right and obviously everything we're going to be discussing here is under the the the lens of will they play next season. We know that there's a chance of a salary cap, but since there's not even offer an offer on the table, it's sort of hard to talk about. And teams I'm sure are experiencing this with free agent deals they're signing.
It's hard to know what the salary cap is gonna be like when we don't even have the framework of one that's been kind of discussed. Well no, there has been there have been but nothing serious. I I don't know. I mean I mean the owners put a salary picap system out there, you know, basically saying there's gonna be a a two fifty eight million cap and a floor of a hundred and a hundred and eighty million. Yeah, yeah, two fifty eight million cap. That's not a realistic proposal here from the pla the map.
be owners. And and and they were going to give them a year to get this done so that for twenty twenty seven they would not play with the cap and they would institute the cap in in the owners' minds in twenty twenty eight. Right, but I feel like that the that's the owners you know giving a deal that they know would never be realistic, so they don't actually have to think about doing that. Because like how would that even work? Would the Mets to trade a bunch of guys to get under the cap? Well and and and it's right, because so twelve teams under the cap would have to raise their total salaries by a total of the altogether of six hundred and
Almost Cooperstown (13:11.76)
ten million aggregately. The teams over the cap would have to cut salaries by a total of five hundred and five million. So actually under a cat system cap system the players would be getting another hundred five million dollars collectively than they're getting right now. So that's what the owners were kinda like, well see what we're doing here? Right, right, right, right. But I I just feel like there's just no way because that that total cap
R like is just so h like it's so low. Two hundred fifty eight you look at teams like the Mets and the Dodgers, they're gonna have to shed so much salary to get there. I don't even know how that's gonna work. And you know, when you when you think about, you know, caps and whatnot, you've got the Dodgers with the deferred compensation that Choey got, getting two million a year and deferring sixty eight million. You know, under a new system, whatever that system is, if we were gonna ever have a cap, which I don't think there will be, I think you've gotta get rid of all of those deferred contracts like that. I think that
That is just completely, you know, usurping the system. 'Cause it makes no sense to do that. If you're gonna 'cause having deferred contracts in a league where there's no salary caps is fine because then it's just okay, you know what, they were smart for signing that deal. So I think with these deferred contracts at the end of the day, if you're going to have a salary cap, you can't have deferred contracts because it just goes against it. It's fine when there's no salary cap, but that you'd just be circumventing. They were you you they were right now it works for teams to be like, look, we can sign more guys right now, but yeah, we'd have to go away from that. So they're they're trying to get the minimum salary for players up up to a million. Right now it's seven hundred and eighty thousand. And that was one of my pet peeves is that I felt like the the lowest, you know, paid players should get paid more. and the highest paid players could take a little less so those lowest paid players can get more. So taking it to a million dollars is a good
Good intention at least. Right, right. I I don't hate the idea of a floor. I think every baseball fan is fine with the idea of the floor. I think it just when you come with a cap you have to be realistic about what the cap is going to be. And two fifty eight just feels too low. Well and and they can negotiate the number. I I agree with you. They can negotiate the number. But here's here's my thought, you know, about a cap and why a cap is wrong. And I wrote about that this w this week. I said, you know, if you're gonna have a cap, okay, the owners can sell their franchises for as much as they possibly can. Right? They can get every
Dollars. So we don't want to have our our our sale price, you know, capped in any way. We want to make as much money as we can. But you players, yeah, you you guys who are on the field to play the game, you can only make a certain amount of money you know, based upon the team only having this much money to pay. You know, you guys work that out. We still can make as much money as we possibly can. Yeah, there's something that feels a little unfair about that. So I I I I think the players should make that argument going, does that make any sense? Because I haven't heard the players really talk about that. But that if that's the case.
What do you do? That's the only problem is that if that's the stance you're going to take, obviously you can't somehow limit what the sale value of the organizations is going to be. So you know. So at that point, then then the only argument is that there shouldn't be a cap because it's right. And then that's what I say. I I look, I I I understood where the cap could have been beneficial to, like I said, lesser paid players. I think there are ways to do this that don't require a cap. And remember, it's the owners locking out the players, supposedly.
Almost Cooperstown (17:16.64)
As of December 2nd, and that that means that they basically just don't want to talk anymore until or they're forcing the players to you know to hear their proposal in a way. They could continue to not not lock the players out and still talk. Right? They they don't they don't have to lock them out. Right, my whole my my ultimate It's choice. Right, I I think like like realistically I'd be fine with like in a perfect world you know who you would get we would get no cap, a floor
And the elimination of deferred contracts. Yeah. I'd like that.
Right. That would be the owners are not gonna go for that. Owners would never go for that. That's absolutely awful for the owners. Like the only thing the owners would probably kind of like in there is the elimination of deferred contracts, mostly because it helps save them from themselves. Like, that's probably the only thing that they're gonna super be on board with. The floor, they're not gonna want, especially if there's no contract. Yeah, deferred contract, ending that would be like like a shot at the Dodgers and anybody who's got the kind of money, you know, to do that. And it's mostly just to be like, you know what? No, we just don't wanna get
Into the nightmare scenario that this could lead us into. So we're just gonna ban it now before it ever gets out of control. But they're never gonna go for a salary floor. They're they're not gonna want to. And and you can't, we've talked about this because I think you brought it up, and then I I I brought this up a couple times about whereas in the NBA they have a salary cap, but they really do it in a different way, and it's done by aprons. Right. So, like I I know we've kind of briefly touched on it here. I don't know if And I don't think it'll work in baseball, is my point. I don't think you can do aprons in baseball because of especially because of the farm system.
systems and how you can those And and the fact that in the NBA docking a team a draft pick is much more punitive than it is in major league baseball. That was why my punishments in my apron things was going to be docking you roster spots. Because I was gonna increase the roster spots by two for every team and then dock you roster spots. Owners will never go for that. Right. So I I I you know it i there there are other ways they could approach this, right? And so an apron system, which I don't think will work in baseball, but something that is maybe
Almost Cooperstown (19:19.692)
you know, reminiscent of that, but in a different way. There's a way for everybody to get something here and it doesn't have to mean that there's a salary cap. And I think the owners are going to go hard at this because their fallback position is strengthened the harder they go for a cap. Right, right. The the owners are probably fine returning to a world where nothing changes. You know, that's that's probably true. And and the players aren't getting
hosed they're not getting the share of revenue that they should get. They they want a a higher share of revenue. Here's what's funny is that if you look at this way, if anything, I think that the players and the owners are kind of thinking, well we might just sort of call each other's bluffs because both of us running this up to the edge and then backing off and just continuing with the status quo. Cause the only group that really is pushing for a salary cap are the fans.
So And e I think the fans are beginning to understand
Based upon what happened this year. Right. There's the inequality that's there that they're saying is there is not if you spend more money and you're in your top ten spending team, you have a better chance of getting to the playoffs if you're a bottom spending team. I think what's for sure. What I do understand and what I think I do understand the fans' frustration are are are there are teams out there that seem content to put a subpar product out on the field because owning a baseball team is not a losing product.
So there are certain teams that seem to fully be taking advantage of that. And I think those are the people that are saying we need a salary floor because they're hoping well, at least if you're forced to spend some amount of money, we'll be better than we are now. Well, some of those teams are taking revenue sharing because they're, you know, the lower spending team for being lousy teams. And fine, they get a pot of money that's returned to them for the the cap paying teams, if you will, the salary luxury tax paying teams, right? And so they're getting fifty million dollars.
Almost Cooperstown (21:18.128)
dollars or 75 million dollars. The pirates and the Rockies. Right, right, but like the pirates are trying to win. The Rays are not spending a ton of money. They're trying to win. You you look at the team. The Brewers aren't spending a ton of money and they're trying to win. It's the teams like the Rockies. The A's.
those teams, the teams that are putting com product on the field that is not really competitive. And and and and you're right. And I and we thought the twins were gonna be there this year and they ended up being pluckier than I thought they were going to be. They still ended up not being great, but they were better than I thought they were gonna be for most of the season. And yet spending the money as we met fans so sadly know doesn't mean anything. And Angel fans, you can you can say the same thing, right? They it's not like Artie Moreno didn't spend a lot of money.
You know, but just didn't spend it wisely. Right, but at least with you're you're a Met fan, you have hope for next season. You're looking at next season and you're going, Okay, you know what? Things could be different. We're gonna go and we're gonna go get Scuble and we got our young guys and things are gonna be different. If you're a caller Rocky fan, what's gonna be different next year?
Well, if you're the Colorado Rockies and I said this a bunch of times organizationally, you gotta pick a lane. Are we gonna be a team that's gonna hit? you know, because we can't get any pitchers with you know there because we can't hit and we still can't pitch. Well they've picked a lane. It's they're going to do neither because they're not going to spend any money because they still make money and ultimately they'll sell the team and make money from that. So why would you spend the money There's a way to be successful in Colorado simply because, you know, you should have an advantage of playing in that circumstance
every eighty one times that other teams can't match as easily because they're not as used to it. Money isn't why the Rockies are necessarily bad, but I do understand the fan perspective of if they were forced to spend some money, it couldn't hurt. Right. Right. So I you know w I don't know how you feel. I've already said I don't think there's gonna be a salary cap. I if if I had to handicap and say do I think there'll be a work stoppage in that that costs games in the season, I would say I I
Almost Cooperstown (23:25.914)
certainly hope not, but yeah, I I I I I I'm gonna try to be realistic here and say as much as I wanna think that there's gonna be some sort of white knight that's gonna salvage this and have it not I I feel like they've got to have some pain in terms of losing gains before they get to where they need to go. I don't think there's gonna be a work stoppage because I don't think either side really knows what they're negotiating for at this point. So I think they're gonna hit a point where they're gonna be like what are we actually fighting over? 'Cause that's what I can't figure out right now.
What the I understand the push for the salary cap, but I neither group is the one really pushing for it. So I can't figure out what the labor stoppage is actually going to happen over because it's it's happening over things that neither side wants. So that's why I think that at the end of the day, I don't think you're gonna get anything because I don't think either side has any reason to want to stop playing. I just think it's you know, to me it seems like this the non salary cap guys on the players' side are are led
By the very best players, the Bryce Harper's and the guys who make the most money, they want to fight for unlimited compensation at the top end of the marketplace. I don't think they're really fighting for the guy who's getting the major league minimum salary. Right. But again, there's no world in which you're getting a salary floor without a salary cap, and the guys that are chiefly in the room doing the negotiating are the ones the least likely to be talking about any kind of salary cap. So I I you know we're
gonna we're gonna be go back and forth on this a few times but it seems pretty likely certainly I am almost positive that December 1st is gonna come and go and there's there's gonna be officially a lockout which really means that you can't talk to people and like you guys can go to each other's weddings but they're not supposed to talk about baseball. Right and that's when you're gonna get and that's when you're gonna get all of these stupid collusion and poaching stories and you get some really funny stories
out of this about how teams figured out how to talk to guys during this period. So if you want some humorous stuff, I'm sure you're gonna get it, but it's gonna be the expense of just the problem with the lockout especially is when there's a lockout there's only one baseball story.
Almost Cooperstown (25:39.597)
The lockout. You don't gotta talk about anything else because nothing's happening other than that. You know, I I I was gonna start this the the lead with this episode being that because you know of of the lockout potentially coming, that one-year contracts could become durigur now because we don't know what's going to happen. Well, I think as we go into especially this offseason, more than any other, this is our story of the week, is that I think you're gonna see more one-year deals than ever before. And I think that's why the Braves going inside.
Evan Phillips to a three year deal is a little weird because I think teams are not going to want to sign guys to long term what it's going to cost. And then Evan Phillips is a fine pitcher, and they paid him a a a decent amount of money to do that. Right, because especially you're in a perspective where you're going to be rushing to sign guys before December 1st because you're going to want to get them on your team before you potentially get locked out and you're not going to have time to negotiate or be able to talk to them. Which is why there's reason to sign, like you say. A guy like Scoobyl will probably sign before December.
December first, because they're gonna have to account for the fact that he was signed before there was any kind of agreement in a cap or non-cap situation. So you can't penalize the team for making a deal and then saying, yeah, the rules all changed, I'm sorry. Right, exactly. Because if you're the Mets, you're not gonna be able to convince Google to sign a one year deal with you. You're gonna have to give them a mega deal. But the Mets are gonna like, listen, you know, we had to give the guy s a seven year, three hundred million dollar deal. What do you mean we now have to get rid of ninety percent of our team? And and the Dodgers are likely to try.
In that situation, to go with a like a six four year $240 million deal. $60 million a year, highest paid pitcher ever, for only four years. Okay. They're gonna try and get him down on the years. That's gonna be the thing is which team is gonna be able to stomach siding him for the longest period? It's gonna take seven years, in my opinion, at least. Seven years or more. The only way you're gonna be able to get away, like and it's a kind of fifty million dollars a year. Well, the only way you can get away with six years is you're the only team will.
Yeah, I don't think that's gonna be more than one team willing to go to six. The highest salary ever where the Mets gave to a pitcher was two pitchers got it. They both got forty-three million. It was Scherzer and Verlander. We all saw how that works. For once and obviously that did not work out, but that is the higher single season salary ever. Yamamoto got three twenty-five for his sing. So Scubu wants to beat both of those numbers. Right. So getting So he's got to get forty-four million over some period of the year, six or seven years is what I think.
Almost Cooperstown (28:09.316)
Would you give him two eight? It's not my money, you bet. Yes. Would you give him
290 for seven. Yes. I'd give them three. Throw it and make another ten. What the hell's ten million? Three. Come on, Terry Scuba. Come on, Dad. So yeah, as as Met fans, that's certainly what we're what we're happy h hoping for. but you know, I think the the one year deal, like you said, is gonna be, you know, w the thing to fall back on because you can pay somebody a stupid amount of money, but as GMs have said, there's no such thing as a bad one year deal from the club's perspective. Right, right, because I and I think unlike the salary.
of the whole salary cap and the labor stoppage with one year deals there's a clear clear winner and loser in one year deals. The winner is the teams. The loser is I think both teams I think I think both parties can win. Both parties can win, but on average players are always gonna want to sign
Longer, of course, because there's a huge amount of risk with a player in a one year deal getting injured. Performance being lousy. Right. Right. And yeah, you maybe you're like, okay, well just signed another one year deal and prove it. But now you're a year older and you're not gonna get that same deal as if you were signing a longer term deal the year after you had a great year on a war. We talk about the Shawman I thing, So Shawman I signed a three year deal, but what really the Mets could have done was after that really great years signed the one stupid year where you paid him way over market for that year and let's see what he's gonna
They didn't do that. They did it for three years and wish they hadn't. I will say if we go back on this podcast, I think we could probably find an episode where I am in not I am not in favor of signing Sean Minaiah. You've never been in five I was never in favor of it, but I think one year would have certainly been better than the three we ended up signing him for. And obviously you're always g the thing is as a fan, it's really easy to think about the benefits of the one year deals 'cause you're not gonna think about the downsides until there's the guy that you only signed for one year and then you he was a free agent the next year and
Almost Cooperstown (30:03.224)
Then you didn't sign him and he went somewhere else and was great. So they're thinking about that. There wasn't much that went on at the general manager meetings last week. that was in Vegas. And I think you only had the two deals. Jake Bowers signed with the Red Sox. I get that was the only like, huh? The Red Sox had Will Wilson Contreras play first base. and I keep going back to Tristan Costas, who's been injured for like two years. So there's another first baseman. He doesn't play anywhere else. Let's just get a bunch of first base in and we'll figure it out later. That's what they did. They need right there, right.
Maybe D H, I don't know. That was a weird but then again
It was a signing the Red Sox were gonna do something. It's weird. It felt like they were just like, We gotta make a move before something happens. But aside from that, and there will be there will be deals made probably as we get towards December first, like Thanksgiving, could be a big deal time because at if you know there's not gonna be any kind of labor movement at this point. So better sign these guys.
Yeah, it's just You're not gonna wanna wait until the lockout is potentially solved because if the lockout isn't solved until mid February, you don't have a lot of time to sign free agents and get them up to speed. And here's what happens, so whoever signs, you know, School for instance and all that whatever team, okay, so you sign them it's it's November twenty seventh or whatever it is before December first. Okay. December first, December second, lockout starts. Can't talk to his team, he just can't talk to his team, can't talk to anybody. So we just signed you to seven years for three hundred million dollars
But you can't talk to anybody. Which means I am sure teams are already thinking teams are forward thinking enough that they're already thinking about what their communication package is going to be to him for that. They know that there's gonna be a lockout coming up here, most likely.
Almost Cooperstown (31:49.856)
And so the you're gonna prepare and try to get him as much stuff, be like, listen, this is all the stuff we have ready for you to get you over to the time period when we're gonna be or hoping to be able to talk to you again. And if you know it's gonna be this long, here's what we have, it's gonna be this long, this is what we're asking of you. Hopefully it doesn't get to this long. Yeah, we hope we have enough material to do another podcast between now and December first, because there's not that much to talk about until we have something to talk about. Right. We're hoping we're gonna get some free agent sightings and we can at least talk about where Scoobyl's going. So you
Keep keep the faith. Hope the the players and the owners kinda can find a place to meet in the middle, but it's gonna take a while if you ask both of us for that to happen.
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
RSS Feed