When Is It Time to Break Up the Band? MLB Teams Facing Big Offseason Decisions
The 2026 MLB regular season is over, the Division Series are underway, and some teams are already facing a difficult question: When is it time to break up the band?
Mark and Gordon take a look at several clubs whose familiar cores may have reached a crossroads. The Phillies still have star power, but after another disappointing finish, does bringing back essentially the same group make sense? Houston won its division, but an aging core and questions about the pitching staff create a similar dilemma.
The guys also look at what comes next for the Blue Jays, Orioles, Tigers and other teams trying to determine whether they need a few changes—or something much bigger.
Before getting to the offseason questions, Mark and Gordon take a tour through some of the most interesting statistical results from the 2026 regular season, including the decline of the 200-hit season, fewer doubles and triples, stolen-base leaders, saves, and a home-run race that finished without anyone reaching 50.
Plus, they recap the opening of the Division Series, including a costly Yankees baserunning decision, dominant pitching, and one of the strangest potential home runs you'll see in a postseason game.
In Episode 726:
- The unusual statistical leaders of the 2026 MLB season
- Why nobody reached 200 hits
- The changing nature of doubles, triples and stolen bases
- Why the 60-save closer may be disappearing
- A surprisingly modest home-run leaderboard
- Early Division Series takeaways
- A bizarre roof play that helped decide a postseason game
- Should the Phillies break up their veteran core?
- Is Houston approaching the end of an era?
- What should Toronto and Baltimore do next?
- Detroit's offseason opportunity
- How the possibility of a 2027 labor stoppage could complicate everything
At some point, continuity stops being stability and starts becoming stagnation. Which MLB teams have reached that point?
Almost Cooperstown is a weekly baseball podcast featuring thoughtful conversations about the Baseball Hall of Fame, baseball history, current MLB topics, player comparisons, statistics and the stories that connect today's game with its rich history.
Thanks again to Mercury Maid for the Intro & Outro music.
Visit AlmostCooperstown.com for original baseball articles, subscribe wherever you listen to podcasts, and follow Almost Cooperstown on YouTube.
In today's podcast, we're gonna take a quick tour through the two thousand and twenty-six season leaders and some of the categories that we're always interested in. We'll take a also a quick tour through through the one game we've had so far in the division series, but our lead story of the week is when is it time to break up the old gang? And we're gonna tell you why. The the old gang are guys that aren't playing anymore. And we'll we'll get to that a little bit later on because there's a lot of teams that are aren't
not only that didn't make the playoffs but are now eliminated. Plus some of the playoff teams too. Right. But th they're still in it. You're not gonna talk about breaking up the band while you're still in the pl in the you know, in the show. But let's talk about some league leaders here because, you know, obviously as the twenty twenty six season came to a close, there were some interesting things. I think one of the more notable ones was that there was no two hundred hit hitter this season that, you know
Or Otto Lopez led the National League at 191. We saw this coming, by the way, because it seemed like near the end of the year that no one was gonna have that week. But this is what's surprising. Luis Arayas at one eighty-five behind him, Fernando Tatis at one eighty one, Yandy Diaz leads the AL at one hundred eighty.
Twenty off of two hundred is shocking. Yeah, I don't know if it's the least league leading hits ever before. I didn't go and check the numbers before that, but it's certainly something like that that low sounds like it's gonna be right there in the full season. I mean it you it's like you still but you look around the rest of the league, it's Brian Reynolds led the and National League and baseball with forty doubles. Well, we got one guy to forty 'cause there was some talk during the season that we weren't gonna have any players at forty forty doubles. Right, right. Wyler Abreu led the AL with thirty eight, but you know
I I'm guessing this is a bit of a you g you 'cause I just noticed Brandon Limo is on this list with thirty six doubles, but he's listed as a met. So I'm thinking that he just got his d his team wrong here. Right, right, right. So yeah, the you know we've talked about doubles and and that there aren't as many doubles and some of that has to do with how good the fielders are, because balls that formally would fall in are being positioned where outfielders can actually catch them and they don't end up being hits at all. Mm-hmm.
Almost Cooperstown (02:09.751)
And then obviously as you keep going down the list, Corbin Carroll for I think like the third or fourth season in a row, yeah. Leads major league baseball with seventeen triples. And and you know, it used to be getting twenty triples or more in a season was a notable achievement. And we don't have many guys get twenty triples these days. I think Curtis Granderson is one of the last guys to to have thir twenty three twenty triples in a season. Jake McCarthy had thirteen triples this year playing in Colorado and that's a season. Well not lead the league,
well Carroll's on the right record. I mean and Carroll has Carroll's had seventeen triples each of the last two seasons, so it's like will he ever get to twenty in a year? Maybe. If you actually played in Colorado, he probably would because that stadium's known for giving up triples. And that's interesting point because the Arizona ballpark also is pretty spacious and so conducive to triple. Nobody else had more than ten. And you know, you don't and it's interesting because clearly national league parks are more conducive to hitting triples because Cody Clemens led right led the American League with seven.
Seven triples led the American League. That's nuts. That's wild. Yeah, that much of a delta. Then, you know, walks, I feel like, you know, Jordan Alvarez had a hundred and nine walks. Bryce Harper had a hundred and seven. So those were your two league leaders where you're not Alvarez. Mike Trout had a hundred and you know had a one seven as well. And that's Schwarber one five. And I would have thought that Juan Soto, the Mets, had he played a full season, he certainly would have had a but he was not a qualified player. He didn't play enough games. Right. And yeah.
And then total bases. unsurprisingly, the guys leading this stategory are the people you'd expect it too. Pete Carr Armstrong with three fifty-seven leading baseball in the National League, and Jordan Alvarez being right behind him at three forty one. Yeah, Junior Camanero, Pete Alonso all were in the top five, and Matt Olsen rounded out that top five and again you're going to see a bit of a a a repetition here because guess who led the league in slugging percentage? Well it was Jordan Alvarez.
With Ki Pika Armstrong right behind him, Jordan Alvarez at six one with Pete Carl Armstrong at five seventy. And so it's like when you get into a lot of these stats because you know, you keep it up because you go to on base and guess who's leading that? It's Jordan Alvarez. Something tells me he had a pretty good season. Yeah, he had what what might be an MVP season in the in the American League. I think people are thinking that. I did notice back to the Schlugging percentage that he was the only guy, Jordan, that had a six hundred or better slugging percentage. Man, it's it's hard to hit in the major leagues.
Almost Cooperstown (04:30.447)
Yeah, well, and but usually your best players, they that's what gave them that you know, that season. I when Otani did it, he was closer to seven hundred.
Right, but at the same time, when you look at your guys, you're saying, okay, four hundred, six hundred, a thousand. If you're taking four hundred on base, six hundred thugging, a thousand OPS, that's an elite season. Yeah, it is a probably a ten war season. Yeah. stolen bases. wh you know, this is a guy a guy if you had asked me who the would lead the league in stolen bases this year, I would have not gotten I followed him all year. I should have I should have bird dogged you on this because I knew that Nassim Nunez of the Washington Nationals, and he was leading the whole season. It wasn't he didn't like come from behind. Right, no, he was ahead of
The whole way I had no idea. Jazz Chisholm said, Hey, look, I'm gonna be the first 50-50 guy. He got forty-one, which was second in the major, which was third in the American League, behind Chandler Simpson and Bobby Witt Jr. Chandler Simpson having forty-six and Bobby at 45. So that's like you he had a lot of steals there. Pete Carl Armstrong came in at 41 to round out your top five. With a 40-40 season to boot. Right, right. So you had a you had four five different guys get forty seals, but I think you as much as we thought the expanded bases were gonna revolutionize stealing in baseball, we've not
seen it change it where suddenly teams are willing to let a guy steal enough bases where he's gonna swipe seventy something bases in a season. And the very best catchers, you know, have, you know, I I I I think Luis Torrens was second with the Mets in the major leagues. I think Henry Davis, if I'm not missing that had it threw out like fifty percent of the base runners, you know, some crazy number like that. But that's that's amazing given the limitations on on throws over and and moving the bases a little closer. Very good and strategic at holding guys on and
You know, we've seen them focus so much on the running game because we've seen the effect. You know, we'll talk about it a little bit, you know, when we talk about the games coming up here, but giving up free bases means a lot. And giving up base runners because they're so precious to begin with, you know, make a big difference when it comes to, you know, getting a guy caught stealing. Now, one of the actually strange predictors of s team success this year is when you look at
Almost Cooperstown (06:33.453)
saves? Who led the league in saves? A lot of them were good teams because you had Brian Baker, Tampa Bay Ray closer, and Cade Smith, Cleveland closer. They were the league leaders at forty one. And they were awesome. With Mason Miller tied with Riley O'Brien, who was the only guy not in the postseason there at thirty eight. David Bednar of the Yankees at thirty five. Chapman of the Ray of the Boston had thirty five. Rafael Iglesias and Joan Duran came in at thirty four, with only Lewis Varland at thirty five, kind of outside the playoffs. But when you look at, you know, your top, you know, not
eight or nine, you know, save guys, all of them about two of them are in the playoffs, kind of says something. And with the all-time record for saves still owned by K Rod up sixty two, it seems like it's gonna be a long way to go for it. You're you're gonna need an exemplary talent at the closer position. Like Mason Miller?
No. Somebody that can be like somebody that like like I it might even be like Mason Miller. The problem is that when you look at it, Mason Miller is now deployed often not in the ninth inning because strategically it's the right thing that's why I don't think we're gonna have a sixty save person ever again, because that at that time the close would only pitch the ninth inning. Now we're like, well wait, what if it makes more sense? Where's the highest leverage situ which makes sense from a baseball standpoint, but that whole r religious nature I think started by Tony La Russa, only the ninth inning and he never
Which when we were thinking about like, okay, yeah, we're saving them so we can face their seven, eight, nine guys this game. But at least they'll pitch the ninth inning. Yeah, exactly. So and then obviously the sexiest of the home run of the categories here, which is who led the league at home runs. And you had two guys tied at the top here, both in the national league, which was PCA and Kyle Schwaber, both hitting forty-five. Right. With Pete Alonso, as much as it pains me to say, leading the American League with 43. And eight guys had forty homers, but as you mentioned, the most being forty five.
Five, that is a very low, high total for home runs. And we have seen other seasons like this where guys, and that does not and we've had recent season where guys have hit tons of home runs. So I think that this is a combination of two or more premier power talents both being injured for large majorities of the season. And we really haven't had a young power hitter like Camonero. Right, right, right. He's that guy. Camanero is that guy. Camanero's gonna have a season where he hits 50 coming up here. Well, and and it made me think, you know, just
Almost Cooperstown (08:52.523)
Now that you know the these two greatest or with with the most home runs in in major league history, if it were not for Barry Bonds' 73 home run season in 2001, he and Hank Aaron never had a fifty home run season, more than fifty. They each hit under fifty every other s and so Aaron never hit more than fifty. Right. Hank Bonds only did it once. Ruth know hit fifty-nine. He did it a couple of times, a couple of times and fifty-four. It is interesting to look at that and
think about like, okay, well what's gonna happen next year when Judge and Otani are presumably back at full health for a full season. I'd guess one of them will probably hit fifty. Yeah, I think that's a that's a that's a pretty good bet. So we now have gotten to the first round of the playoffs. Through the through the wild card round. I I think we can go through what was in a in a sense the most perfunctory of the games, which was shockingly game one of the Rays and the Yankees because of division series here, because that was about as ho-hom a game as possible as the Yankees had taken out the Red Sox to get to the division series, beating them.
And we'll talk about that. And we will talk about the Rankees and the Red Sox and what happens with the Red Sox going forward. But the Yankees coming off of their series victory proceeded to get one hit over eight innings of brilliant pitching here by but what a hit it was. so you know that this that is going to go down as one of the more bonehead plays of all time. So Austin Wells, the Yankee catcher, not much of a hitter. then he's coming up late in the game, and I think it was the the eighth inning, and he pulls a ball down the right field line and he starts.
Starts running and he's chugging around there. No, no, there's nobody out. and for some inexplicable reason decides he's gonna try for a triple. Now this guy is a catcher who runs like a catcher. It was shades of Daniel Vogelbach running to third when he shouldn't have been when you're just like, why are you going? So so he's going to third. Now, you know, you know, having a runner and scoring position would have been great for the Yankees at that point late in the game, and he ran
What was the only hit of the game into an out at third base? And the old saying you never make the first or the third out at third base obviously was not pounded into Austin Wells's head. Especially in a game where you hadn't gotten any hits, getting having that guy I get why you would want to get to third so badly there. But
Almost Cooperstown (11:11.007)
Y you can't run your team out of an inning there. You got you got a guy on second base, you haven't had anybody on base the whole day. You got a guy on scoring position now. Let's build an inning. But but credit to Rasmussen, Drew Rasmussen, who was great all year, probably the most unheralded pitcher in all of baseball this year, because you you don't realize that he's this has just been what he did all year. and Cole was good, but he gave him one home run, you know, and that's that was all it took. That was the game. And then you know, the other AL game was also as kinda equally quiet from one
Team offensively as the White Sox shut down and shut out the Guardians 3 0 behind a Murakami home run and a couple of hits in one inning. Well they they hit their home runs, but the the story of the game was Grant Taylor. Right. Grant Taylor comes in throwing four innings of just absolute lockdown, unhittable relief. I think it you know it's unprecedented for not Brunson it has happened before, but it hasn't happened in a long time. I think it was like Pedro Borbone of the Cincinnati Reds in the seventies, who pitched four innings of relief. and he got the
that that is a save situation, although he could it could they could have given it to somebody else because it's or did he get the win right because he didn't pitch four innings, right? I don't think the starting no, he p he did pitch four innings. No, no. The the starting pitcher was no, it was opener for the for the opener. So the official scorer can give the win to whoever he wants. I assume he gave it. I don't even know. They gave him the save. They gave him the save, so he didn't get the win. Even so he somebody else got the win for doing much less than did Grant Taylor. So, you know, great on the White Sox.
You know, who, you know, hit the ball out of the ballpark and have played, you know, good defense at this point and gotten better pitching than I think we would have thought, considering their approach. And the White Sox had dispatched the Astros to nothing to get here, and we'll talk about them. But to you know, just finish rounding out as we move over to the National League. The Dodgers beat the Braves in a
Expected. You know, the Dodgers played Dodger baseball in that game. Yeah, yeah, right. You get out to a lead, you're out 3-1, you add some tack on runs, you get the 5-1, and you give up a two-run shot to Albies in the ninth inning to make it 5-3 against Tanner Scott. So it's a little exciting, but then you close it out. Then close it out. Scuba was great. You got the home runs you needed. I I think the problem for the the Braves in the series is your pitchers aren't gonna come back till so late in the series that you're in a almost weird must-win game two series.
Almost Cooperstown (13:32.394)
situation here because you're not gonna have time even if Sale and and Molly come back and pitch these other games. If to be the Dodgers three games in a row potentially to win this series, that's gonna be really rough. And the Dodgers starters are sort of lined up, you know, now all the way there they're rested and the Braves had to work so hard to get into this in burning out you know Sale, who probably won't pitch again until game three in Atlanta is what I'm thinking. He'll he'll pitch that game. So yeah I I I think the the Dodgers are in a in a good situation. I wouldn't put it past the the Braves
To somehow, you know, make it interesting. Make it interesting at this point. Right, but I think we have to get to the most interesting, obviously, or most controversial, shall we say, of the endings of the division, first games of the division series with the Brewers taking down the Padres, the Padres having thoroughly dispatched the Cubs to get here. And you know, you you get a start from Jacob Mizerowski of only four innings, so that's surprising in and of itself. And you score two runs off the guy in the second inning by getting what we said is the hardest thing to do in the playoffs. We're always saying this on this podcast in the playoffs.
bunch of runs obviously. Just to get bunch of hits against a really good pitcher, right? Well, what they do against the best pitcher in all of baseball this year, and I think I can say that with all assurance, is they get three straight singles in the second inning and they score two runs. Right. That must have felt real good for them. And you know, but at the end of the day, the Brewers played Brewer baseball. They didn't give up many more runs than that. They kept chipping away. They kept chipping when they hit home runs. Right. These are the Brewers. They don't hit home runs. Except they did that game. And they did this game and then
Ahead late in the game, Ty Franz, who's had a morassic comes up, hits a bomb to left field, way up there, way up there at the top of the stadium, and it bounces off of the roof all the way down into Jackson Churio's glove. Who's standing there? So you gotta think about Churio going, Let's see, it's out there and all that stuff. That might be no
Stand over here and it hits the stanchion on the closed roof, you know, which actually drops right into his glove. Drops right into his glove. And Ty France is like he's like, That's a home run. Right, right. AJ Przezinski in the booth like, That's a home run. But Joe Davis, who obviously had read the rules, knew before anybody else was immediately like, Nope, by the rules, that ball coming off the roof here, as long as the ball was in play, the ball is in play. The ball was in play, out.
Almost Cooperstown (15:49.548)
So had the ball hit the the this the stanchion up there and gone into foul territory and landed you know in instead of landing in Churio's glove, it would have been a foul ball. Well it has to it has to land in the field of play. It has to land in the field of play and it also has to hit off the roof in in fair territory. Fair territory, which they had to go to the replay 'cause the thing was hit so high and so far. Didn't you say it was like a home run in every ballpark? Yes, home run in every other ballpark except that one. So two outs, b top of the ninth inning, a man on base. That is the game going ahead the
Go ahead home right to bring in Mason Miller Mason Miller to close that game out. man. The pu you know how how do the Padres recover from something like that? That's and that's what they're trying to get up to today. So But I mean those were obviously our division series. So then we have to kind of look at we we saw that the the Padres advanced, we saw that the Braves advanced, we saw that the the White Sox and the Yankees advanced. So what about the teams that were sent home? Right, the guys that didn't advance. Yes, we're looking at the Red Sox, the Astros, the Phillies, and the Cubs.
I think if we're talking about the teams, I think it's interesting 'cause you can kind of draw draw a line between two groups of them. You've got the Cubs and the Red Sox, and then you've got the Yankees and the I'm sorry, you've got the Cubs and the Red Sox and you've got the Phillies and the Astros. And I think you feel very differently about this postseason if you are Philly and Astro fan compared to where you are if you're a Red Sox Cub fan. I think there's a lot more frustration on the Red Sox Cub fan level because you think your team is better than this and they did not perform well this season. And not not say
That the Phillies and the Astros did perform well this season, but your frustration with the team is much differently because we'll get into that in a moment. Right. So the lead story is when is it time to break up the band? And I think what we're when I I think what we're suggesting is the Phillies who they put the band together this last year with the complete understanding that this might be the last roundup. I think we talked about that on our season preview podcast. and I think the Astros are in the same position. Right, because the Astros is like, you know, you got another season out of Jose Altuvi. That was it.
impressive. You know, you you you've got for his age it was impressive. That's the problem. Right. And and that's where you're getting it's like what what is the astral core of that team? What where are they going with that team? You know, they survived an AL West to win the AL West, and that's the bet really the most generous You take it. No, you take it. Right, right, exactly. The Phillies got there, but but we saw that this was a team that looked old towards the end of this year.
Almost Cooperstown (18:19.305)
And you've got a bunch and and you know you have some nightmare deals on this team right now. You look at a guy like Trey Turner, who's under contract for seven more seasons and he looks ancient. Had a bad year this year. Right. Aaron Nola's got four more seasons. And Zach Wheeler needs a deal. So what do you do if you're Philadelphia? Because I can't im you know, you've got s a bunch of young talent between Christopher Sanchez, you're hoping Andrew Painter, you know, you're pretty young. You've got some young physician talent.
Them not a ton, but you've got Shorber, Ryomuto, Bryce Harper and Dre Turner. And Brandon Marsh. Right. You've got all these guys that what are you gonna do? Is it they've been there forever, it seems. Right. There you you you made the postseason this year, but if you keep all those guys and you don't make it next year
then all of the guys you would want to trade are just that much less valuable. So is it time to break up the band in Philadelphia? Well and and of course we're not Philly fans, so we probably shouldn't be the people to to answer this question. But my sense would be from Philly fans going, I can't watch this again. I don't want to watch another season like this where my my bullpen at the end of the year isn't isn't what I hoped it would be. and I stopped hitting even though I've got two of the marquee hitters in baseball on my team and we can't hit. How does that make any sense?
Where like had the Mets not made the NLCS in twenty four, you'd be in a similar situation to that where it's like you you really want to run it back with this group again? Like, I don't understand how it's gonna get better. They're just older now. And that that's the old false idols thing, right? 'Cause you're right. The Mets ended up, you know, rolling the same guys out there the next year and it failed miserably in the Phillies case. You know, had they won the Lake Hall series against the Braves, that might have also led them to believe that maybe we could hang on for another year, d depending maybe and on where
So I think Dave Dembrowski, who, you know, as as as a possible Hall of Fame executive at some point in the future, I think a lot of people feel that way about him. He's not the most dynamic or
Almost Cooperstown (20:22.579)
Or he's he's not go out and sign guys. He'll sign guys, but he's not gonna make these big trade deals. He's not like you know, Padres GM GM. And so, you know, he's he he he's basically, you know, not going anywhere, but I get the funny feeling that they're gonna make some major changes on that team. Right and it's interesting because you look at a team like the Astros, who I think you could argue that their overall talent level is worse and thus the reason to make changes is a lot more obvious. But at the same time you play in a significantly worse division.
And so you won the division this year. You don't really you could just kinda stand pat and there's a decent chance you won it next year. Well, you you know your pitching this year let you down, obviously, and you you you didn't get the start in the playoffs from Hunter Brown that you hoped for when you really needed in a in a three game series. But I I think the the you know, remember that Carlos Correa is back on that team, although he didn't play in the playoffs because he's hurt again. And so between he and Altuve and you know and you have it you have a guy in his prime in
in Alvarez. Yeah Alvarez. But around the around there you've got other guys. These guys are taking up too much space out there, you know, in terms of Altuve, I think, and Correa on your roster. and you don't have enough pitching, so you got to go out and rebuild your pitching staff. Pitching used to be the hallmark of the Astros. And and now they're like a team that doesn't score that many runs and doesn't have great pitching. Right. So well then their bullpen is, you know, has got a few guys near that that we've known traditionally, but it's far from what it was.
When Hater was there and they were at their very best. And that's not even it's not even playoff teams that are necessarily also thinking up the band 'cause I am sure, much to the chagrin of Blue Jay fans, there there's a bit of you being like, what is this team? Ave we had the amazing run in twenty twenty five and then we you know Is it just a bad year? Is it just a bad year? Are you gonna really tell me Alejandro Kirk is that important to this team that just removing him from the lineup for the majority of the year and from catching is maybe it's Addison Barger.
Obviously Vladdy had a terrible season. He made some dumb comments. Right, so if you're the Blue Jays and Vlad Grail Jr. has a bad season, you're not winning. You know, but if you're gonna be a good team or a great team, you know that he has to be one of the guys who's great. So almost the moment that he's not
Almost Cooperstown (22:37.269)
Right, but I think what we did see there is that as much as the moves that they did make to try and replace Bo Bachet, not having Bo Bachet in that lineup made a difference this season. Yeah, they you know, and for a team that, you know, you scratch your head going, How can these guys not hit? Because they could pitch. I mean they had and they gotta you know, they found the closer in Louis Varland this year that, you know, they've been looking for for a long time. And th they wished he'd been, you know, at in that position when their teams were trying to make it a few years ago. Right, it was great in the postseason last year, I remember that, but you know, you just overall you look at that team and you go, Okay
What do we change? another team that I think might be in that situation, and we've talked about them a lot, is the Orioles. Yeah, well, and and that's a that's a weird team because, you know, they have lots of They already started it. They got rid of Rutschman, right? But they still have, you know, Jackson Holiday and Gunnar Henderson. They have these guys. They're not necessarily babes anymore, but they're still young, you know, players. I I don't know what you're expecting, you know, from these guys.
lit zero pitchers. Yeah, yeah, right. Grayson Rodriguez, what's he done for them? Like none of them are some of them injury trades, you know, not of them around. But you you turn none of these young pitchers into any kind of reliable starters. So I think that's another team you're looking at where it's like, okay, is it time to kind of
break this up. I thought that we were gonna be looking at that with the San Diego Padres, but they've managed to save that off with their second half run this year. Yeah, yeah, and obviously that not only are they still playing, but you look around and I and I pick them to do well in the playoffs only 'cause I say, you know, if it all came together for the Padres, they're a really good team. It hasn't, so there's a reason for we'd say, well if it keeps not happening, then why do we keep doing the same thing over and over again? So it'll take the playoff run to sort of set the Padres as to what they are going to do to get the expectations. Because you they've got the bullpen.
They've got some starters, you know, they got some everyday players. And the reason why, you know, a team like the Mets isn't on this list is spoiler alert, they they already did that. They already got ri they've already kind of gone into breaking everything up into the rebuilding mode. That's what happened this season when they traded everybody away at the deadline. And if you watched them at all this last season, you would have seen a parade of guys coming out of the bullpen that nobody knew.
Almost Cooperstown (24:51.919)
To patch it together as best they can to beat the Phillies and to keep going. if they had their full compliment of of A-level pitchers, you know, that's a pretty, you know, pretty good team and not too old either, really. So so question, there's one more team we haven't talked about. I just think it's interesting because of what does this team do now? You're the Detroit Tigers going into this offseason. What do you do?
Designed Tarek Scoobyl. Do you got right? No, that would be a brilliant move. If you went inside Scuba, you would look like the smartest team in the world. So that's probably not gonna happen when it comes to the Tigers. But it's just interesting to think about the. I think you're right. I think that's a team that has to think, do we need to to break up the band? Especially because one, it was a super young band. It wasn't like you had all these free agent signings you had gone out and made other than Framer. But now you've got Framer Valdez and a team that didn't make the postseason this year due to a combination.
Of injury luck and a slow ever being able to get off the mat after a slow start.
It's just interesting to think about that team in terms of like what do you do next? Yeah, I think I think when you you think about from the Tigers is you know, they're everyday players. You know, Riley Green had a great season, so certainly he's you know, he's placed himself among the better players in the American League. But you go around it, they don't really have a host of guys that you think, I'm I'm nervous that this guy's coming to the plate in a big situation. They need more of those guys. He hit th you know, D Dylan Ding Dingler Dingler Dingler hit two forty and twenty seven homers. Torkelston hit twenty six homers.
hit 230. They need another
Almost Cooperstown (26:25.525)
Riley Green in that lineup. You know, Kevin McGonagall had a really good season. Rookie season. Really good season. But I need some, you know, Kerry Carpenter played right field. He played 81 games there. He hit 208. Real disappointing. I had I had high hopes for him having a good year. It's funny because, you know, Luis Arrayas is doesn't have a contract for next year, and he'd be an interesting guy to plug in at second base if you're in Detroit. Right. I I think that's an interesting, you know, McKin they to me, I look at that team and they need outfield help.
That's what I see when I look at that team. They had basically besides Riley Green. Besides Riley Green, center field and right field were a nightmare all year for them. Carrie Carpenter did not have a good year this year. So that's a team there. If there's a premier outfield talent on the market, I would be looking to sign him there. Because when you look at the rest of their pitchers, you're like, Okay, you know, it's like yeah, we don't have you if we go sign school, we're back in it. Yeah, exactly. I think they they they could do that and in a division, you know, in the American League West central, which is not gonna be that much better next year than
It was this year, I think, and I don't think there's gonna be big changes. and the whole thing that looms all of over all of this, you talk about breaking up the band and and making changes in your organization is the lockout possibility. Right. Right. Because like when are you gonna be able to do stuff if you are, you know, locked out and you can't make deals until the spring, then it's gonna be a free-for-all to figure out what kind of a team we're putting on the field for, however many games they'll play in twenty twenty-seven. And and games they will play, I'm hoping for a whole season, but the more I hear about it, the more I think it seems like you
You know, there's gonna be some time is just to make a point, which is gonna make me nuts. Right, 'cause you know, you have teams with young guys that are coming up that are having good seasons and you know, you're a team like like the Tigers who got a year out of Cater Montero, who I think a lot of people don't have not heard of this guy who don't know who had a very good season for them and would look like to be a guy you're gonna be like, he's gonna be up there with Framer at the top of our rotation next year. Well you lose a season and all of a sudden he's he it's gonna be his year t age twenty seven season. Now now you you've lost what is a prime year control of that guy potentially. So
Yeah, I think, you know, it's it's hard to break up the the the band, you know, sometimes for the fans to say, you're gonna take a w a way these guys that we love so much, but when you don't win, you know, the fans have to begin to understand going really we we want a championship. And I think fans you have mo an fans are so much more analytically minded that I think they are much more willing to hop off with the band than they used to be. You know, getting rid of your superstars back in the day used to be unthinkable. You know, we talk about Tom Seaver getting traded to the Reds. that was unthinkable. Right.
Almost Cooperstown (28:52.799)
But but you look I I am sure there would have been fans that would have said the same thing about Bryce Harper and you know, or or Trey Turner. But we look at who those guys are now and go, Maybe it's the right move. You know where I'm hearing Bryce Harper could possibly go and there's been no official talk about this, Vegas. He's from Vegas.
And they're gonna so they're they're in Sacramento, so he plays a year in Sacramento. and then he ends up going to Las Vegas when they move to Las Vegas. He's from Vegas. I would believe I would believe that a lot more if he took a one year deal with the Phillies this year. Yeah, yeah. We'll s we'll we'll see that. I he would rather play in Philadelphia than spend a year rotting in Sacramento. So the the division series will be ending at the end of this week. and we will come back with another podcast where we'll talk about the beginning of the league championship series 'cause that does start
just before our next podcast will drop, but we'll preview that and and talk about what's going on and we'll have another lead story of the week.
Apple Podcasts
Spotify
RSS Feed