The 2026 MLB awards are in, and four major awards were unanimous. But while the MVP and Cy Young races produced little controversy, the National League Rookie of the Year voting certainly did.
In Episode 730 Mark and Gordon discuss the winners, including Pete Crow-Armstrong, Yordan Alvarez, Cam Schlittler, and Jacob Misiorowski. They debate Sal Stewart's controversial Rookie of the Year victory over Mets outfielder Carson Benge and whether voters placed too much emphasis on home runs and RBIs.
Then the conversation turns to the biggest story of the offseason: MLB's looming labor confrontation.
With a potential lockout approaching, could a proposed $258 million salary cap and $180 million salary floor reshape baseball? Would a cap really improve competitive balance? And what would happen to teams like the Mets and Dodgers, whose payroll commitments could exceed the proposed limits?
In this episode:
The unanimous MVP and Cy Young winners and the Rookie of the Year controversy.
Pat Murphy, Will Venable, and the Manager of the Year awards.
Why a salary floor might accomplish more than a salary cap.
Whether Shohei Ohtani's deferred compensation would work under a new system.
Why owners and players may both have reasons to avoid a prolonged work stoppage.
How labor uncertainty could encourage more one-year free-agent contracts.
What it might take for the Mets or Dodgers to sign Tarik Skubal.
Whether long-term contracts make sense when baseball's financial rules could change.
Will baseball's owners and players find common ground, or is another work stoppage inevitable?
Almost Cooperstown is a weekly baseball podcast featuring thoughtful conversations about the Baseball Hall of Fame, baseball history, current MLB topics, player comparisons, statistics and the stories that connect today's game with its rich history.
Thanks again to Mercury Maid for the Intro & Outro music.
Visit AlmostCooperstown.com for original baseball articles, subscribe wherever you listen to podcasts, and follow Almost Cooperstown on YouTube.
Time Chapter
00:00 MLB awards are in — four unanimous winners
00:45 Sal Stewart vs. Carson Benge: NL Rookie of the Year controversy
02:50 Cy Young winners and Shohei Ohtani's pitching future
05:50 AL Rookie of the Year and unanimous MVPs
08:15 Pat Murphy, Will Venable and Managers of the Year
11:40 MLB's proposed salary cap and floor
14:00 Deferred contracts and the Ohtani question
17:15 Could baseball work without a salary cap?
19:45 Competitive balance, payrolls and revenue sharing
23:20 Will a lockout cost regular-season games?
25:40 Why one-year free-agent deals could become common
27:00 What will it cost to sign Tarik Skubal?
30:00 Early offseason signings and the December deadline